Risk Flags
6- Patriots RB Committee
New England has historically utilized multiple backs and lacks a clear lead-back identity. Henderson faces potential competition from draft picks or free agent additions in what appears to be a transitional Patriots offense.
- Usage & Volume
Henderson's role fluctuates significantly based on game script and opponent. Despite establishing lead-back status mid-season, playoff usage varied dramatically (60-4 snap disadvantage vs Denver due to game conditions). Role remains dependent on Stevenson's health and coach decisions.
- Backfield Split Uncertainty
Henderson is projected to begin 2026 on the smaller end of a backfield split with Rhamondre Stevenson after splitting touches fairly evenly in the Super Bowl. His playoff usage varied dramatically based on game script, including just 3 carries in the AFC Championship.
- RB Committee Ceiling
Rhamondre Stevenson is the clear pass-down and high-leverage RB1 under Mike Vrabel, limiting Henderson to ~39% of snaps. Both are under contract for 2026 and beyond, making a role reversal unlikely without injury.
- Backfield Committee
Rhamondre Stevenson holds a 4-year, $36M extension with full guarantees through 2026, structurally locking Henderson into a co-starter role for at minimum two more seasons. McDaniels' 21-personnel-heavy scheme (top-3 in NFL usage) distributes carries by design — there is no near-term path to 60%+ workhorse usage without a Stevenson health event.
- Coaching Trust
Henderson totaled just 45 scrimmage yards and averaged 2.5 YPC in Super Bowl LX while Stevenson remained the preferred back in high-leverage situations. Coaches demonstrably leaning on Stevenson when the stakes peak is a real ceiling risk for Henderson's role expansion in 2026.