Risk Flags
6- Injury Concerns
Pearsall has missed significant time in both NFL seasons (11 games in 2024, 10 games in 2025) due to a PCL sprain that re-aggravated in Week 17 and won't fully heal without complete rest. This durability pattern severely limits his floor and redraft value.
- Chronic Knee Injuries
Pearsall's PCL injury plagued him all season (9 games missed) and re-aggravated in Week 17. Missed playoffs entirely except for questionable status. This is his second year with major durability issues (11 games in 2024, 10 in 2025).
- Usage & Volume
Target share has fallen to just 7% in his final logged game (W20), and the season trend shows both target share and snap share moving down. His floor is dangerously low if he cannot assert himself against a newly competitive WR room.
- Target Volume
The 49ers are all but certain to move on from Brandon Aiyuk, Jauan Jennings is a free agent and Ricky Pearsall has struggled to stay healthy. The team will likely find a difference-making wide receiver, adding external depth threat uncertainty.
- WR Competition Incoming
The 49ers are projected to draft a WR in the first round (picks 27-28) and ESPN reports they'll seek external additions this offseason. This directly threatens Pearsall's path to a WR1 role even if Aiyuk departs and Jennings leaves.
- Role Uncertainty
With only Pearsall and Demarcus Robinson under contract for 2026, and Jennings potentially returning on a $22M/year deal, Pearsall's target share remains unclear. He's never been a true WR1 and could be relegated to WR3 duties if SF adds talent.