Risk Flags
6- Target Volume
Despite suiting up for all 17 regular-season games in 2025, Musgrave totaled just 24 catches for 252 yards (on 31 targets) without a single touchdown. In Week 17, Josh Whyle played 28 snaps to Musgrave's 18 in a pass-heavy script, suggesting the Packers have leaned on Whyle more than Musgrave in recent weeks when they actually need to throw the ball.
- Usage & Volume
Fellow tight end John FitzPatrick had a 70 percent snap share while Musgrave played 52 percent of Green Bay's offensive snaps. Even though Tucker Kraft's injury opened the door for Musgrave to recapture a big role on the offense, there were games when he played fewer snaps than John FitzPatrick and Josh Whyle.
- Depth Chart
Tucker Kraft is ahead of schedule in his ACL recovery and expected to return Week 1 of 2026, immediately pushing Musgrave back to a backup role. GM Brian Gutekunst has indicated extension talks with Kraft are a priority, cementing him as the long-term TE1.
- Starter Threat
Tucker Kraft is 'right on schedule' with his ACL recovery (torn Week 9, 2025) and expected back for Week 1, 2026; Matt LaFleur called him 'a big focal point of our offense.' Musgrave has no viable path to meaningful targets in Green Bay once Kraft is healthy.
- Production Ceiling
As the de facto TE1 following Kraft's injury, Musgrave totaled just 24 catches, 252 yards, and zero touchdowns on 31 targets across 17 games—a disqualifying TE1 audition that raises genuine ceiling concerns regardless of landing spot.
- Target Competition
Musgrave is a clear TE2 behind Tucker Kraft (value 4820 vs 1294), who is expected back early in 2026 and is the front office's extension priority. As long as both are healthy in Green Bay, Musgrave has no path to a featured receiving role.