Risk Flags
7- Depth Chart
During McIntosh's recovery, the Seahawks' backfield has evolved dramatically. Kenneth Walker won Super Bowl MVP and is negotiating a major extension, Zach Charbonnet tore his ACL in playoffs but holds dynasty value of 3742.0, and George Holani (733.0) has earned the RB3 role McIntosh was competing for.
- Injury Concerns
McIntosh suffered his second ACL tear in three years during July 2025 training camp and was placed on IR. ACL recovery for RBs typically requires 12-18 months, pushing meaningful return to mid-to-late 2026 at earliest with significant re-injury risk.
- Crowded Backfield
Kenneth Walker, George Holani, Velus Jones, and Cam Akers are ahead of McIntosh on the depth chart, with Charbonnet also on the roster. McIntosh was fighting for the No. 3 job before injury; his recovery window may miss prime opportunity window.
- Draft Capital
Seattle spent the 32nd overall pick on Notre Dame RB Jadarian Price, the first first-round RB investment since Rashaad Penny (2018). This is a generational commitment to the position that immediately relegates McIntosh to depth-chart irrelevance behind Walker III, Charbonnet, and now Price.
- Injury Recovery
McIntosh tore his ACL in July 2025 training camp (surgery August 12, 2025), missing the entire 2025 season. He is expected to return for 2026, but is entering camp at 26 years old still proving full recovery — a notoriously difficult combination at RB.
- Age Concerns
RB age 26 — entering/past typical value cliff
- Contract Status Uncertainty
As a 2023 seventh-round pick with minimal NFL production and two ACL tears, McIntosh faces significant roster security concerns. The Seahawks signed Walker to a likely extension and drafted Damien Martinez in 2025, leaving McIntosh without a clear path to touches even if healthy.