Risk Flags
6- Unproven NFL Starter
Milroe has minimal NFL starting experience and was acquired mid-season, making it unclear if Seattle views him as a long-term franchise QB or a bridge option. His actual NFL competency remains largely unproven against consistent top-tier competition.
- Depth Chart
Sam Darnold just won the Super Bowl with a 14-3 record and signed a 3-year, $100.5M deal; Seattle's GM publicly committed to keeping him 'for a long time,' eliminating any realistic path to the starting job in Seattle for at least 2-3 seasons.
- Usage & Volume
Milroe finished 2025 as the third-string QB behind Darnold and Drew Lock, logging just 2% snap share across 3 game appearances with -1.6 total fantasy points on the season — effectively irrelevant on the active roster.
- Blocked Pathway
Darnold just led Seattle to a Super Bowl championship and is signed through 2027 at age 28, creating a multi-year roadblock for Milroe's starting opportunity. Insider reports suggest Seattle may extend Darnold's contract this offseason after his elite performance.
- Depth Chart Ceiling
Milroe is locked in as Seattle's #3 QB behind Sam Darnold — who just led the Seahawks to a Super Bowl title and owns two years remaining on a $100.5M deal — and Drew Lock as the established backup. Darnold's championship performance has permanently cemented his franchise QB status through at least 2027 with no near-term path opening.
- Development Trajectory
After a rookie campaign producing just 2% snap share and -1.6 total fantasy points across three appearances, Milroe has accumulated virtually zero live NFL reps. Entering Year 2 with the same depth chart above him, meaningful developmental opportunities remain scarce and the clock is ticking on his rookie deal.