J.J. McCarthy

QB · #33

MIN · QB · Age 23

FLEX

J.J. McCarthy's recent carry share signals a unique rushing role for a quarterback, but his overall value remains at QB38.

Role & volume

Over the last four games, McCarthy has averaged a 10% snap share and maintained a consistent zero target share, indicating he is primarily functioning as a rushing quarterback.

Projected role

Looking ahead to Week 19, McCarthy's projected usage remains similar, with his team likely relying on him for significant rushing volume despite his lower overall value rank.

Range (floor–ceiling)

Given his recent performance and role, McCarthy offers a floor of around 8 PPR points per game but caps at around 23.5 PPR points, making him a FLEX option with upside in rushing scenarios.

Intel may be outdated · updated 7 days ago

Current statusMIN

Our read vs. the market

Beta

No call yetLow confidence

The QB position isn't modeled yet — no call.

Our own read · beta — not a trade price.

Risk & Opportunity Analysis (3 flags)

Risk Flags

Depth Chart / Role
McCarthy lost the 2026 quarterback competition to Kyler Murray, who signed with Minnesota in March 2026 and was named the Week 1 starter; McCarthy has held a stable QB2 role since, with some reporting suggesting Carson Wentz has closed the gap for the primary backup job.
Injury Concerns
McCarthy dealt with a hand issue in 2025 and took an ankle injury in the 2026 preseason that briefly sidelined him, not considered long-term; a recurring injury pattern could complicate any spot-start opportunity if one arises.

Opportunity Flags

Injury Contingency Value
Kyler Murray carries a notable injury history of his own; if Murray misses time, McCarthy is the presumptive next man up with meaningful 2025 starting reps on tape, giving him real spot-start spike potential.

Format Comparison

J.J. McCarthy — Format Comparison

Format	Value	vs Best
PPR SFBest	1,218	—
PPR 1QB	1,030	-188