Donaven McCulley

FA · WR · Age 26

Dynasty rank

—

Hold Stable

Tier

—

Consensus

Debated

What’s driving the value

Case for

Age / window

age 26 WR

Minor

Situation

Multiple tailwinds

Notable

Case against

Pedigree / rank

WR99 · Tier ?

Minor

Neutral: Production trend

Analysis

Donaven McCulley is an undrafted 2026 rookie WR who signed with the Denver Broncos after converting from quarterback (Indiana) to receiver (Michigan). He carries a 'pure backup' grade, sits at the bottom of a crowded Broncos WR depth chart behind established options, and projects as a practice-squad/roster-bubble player with no meaningful dynasty trade value (currently 0). The intriguing parts of his profile — a 'power forward' frame, YAC ability, and developmental traits — are offset by real concerns about separation and route-running polish typical of a recent position-switcher. For dynasty purposes he is a deepest-leagues-only watch-list dart with effectively no acquisition cost. Recommendation: HOLD/AVOID for standard formats; in 35+ roster leagues he's a free stash to monitor through training camp, but do not spend any real asset to acquire him.

Scenarios (3)

Practice squad stashlikely▲ +0%

Cut / out of leaguepossible▼ -10%

Depth role via injuryunlikely▲ +25%

Current statusFree Agent

Prospect Profile2026 Class

BMI

Risk & Opportunity Analysis (5 flags)

Risk Flags

Draft Capital
McCulley went undrafted in 2026 and signed with Denver as a UDFA with a 'pure backup' grade, meaning essentially zero invested draft capital and a steep climb just to make the 53-man roster.
Depth Chart
He sits at the very bottom of a crowded Broncos WR room and is a training-camp/practice-squad bubble candidate rather than a rotational contributor.
Skill Profile
Scouting reports flag limited separation and raw route running for a converted-QB-to-WR who is still developing the position after transferring from Indiana to Michigan.

Opportunity Flags

Traits Profile
A 'power forward' build with size and yards-after-catch ability, plus a former-QB background, gives him a developmental-traits ceiling that a creative staff could try to develop on the practice squad.
Acquisition Cost
With a trade value of 0 he is a zero-cost waiver/watch-list flier in only the deepest dynasty formats; any role would be pure profit.

← Back to Player Explorer

Donaven McCulley

FA · WR · Age 26

Dynasty rank

—

Hold Stable

Tier

—

Consensus

Debated

What’s driving the value

Case for

Age / window

age 26 WR

Minor

Situation

Multiple tailwinds

Notable

Case against

Pedigree / rank

WR99 · Tier ?

Minor

Neutral: Production trend

Analysis

Scenarios (3)

Practice squad stashlikely▲ +0%

Cut / out of leaguepossible▼ -10%

Depth role via injuryunlikely▲ +25%

Current statusFree Agent

Prospect Profile2026 Class

BMI

Risk & Opportunity Analysis (5 flags)

Risk Flags

Draft Capital
McCulley went undrafted in 2026 and signed with Denver as a UDFA with a 'pure backup' grade, meaning essentially zero invested draft capital and a steep climb just to make the 53-man roster.
Depth Chart
He sits at the very bottom of a crowded Broncos WR room and is a training-camp/practice-squad bubble candidate rather than a rotational contributor.
Skill Profile
Scouting reports flag limited separation and raw route running for a converted-QB-to-WR who is still developing the position after transferring from Indiana to Michigan.

Opportunity Flags

Traits Profile
A 'power forward' build with size and yards-after-catch ability, plus a former-QB background, gives him a developmental-traits ceiling that a creative staff could try to develop on the practice squad.
Acquisition Cost
With a trade value of 0 he is a zero-cost waiver/watch-list flier in only the deepest dynasty formats; any role would be pure profit.

Donaven McCulley

Prospect Profile2026 Class

Athletic Profile

Risk Flags

Opportunity Flags

Donaven McCulley

Prospect Profile2026 Class

Athletic Profile

Risk Flags

Opportunity Flags