Fantasy Heartbeat
GuillotineDraftRankingsTrade Calculator
Connect league

© 2026 Fantasy Heartbeat

  • Blog
  • Tools
  • Track Record
  • Pricing
  • Help
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Disclaimers
  • Contact

Fantasy Heartbeat is an independent tool and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by the National Football League (NFL), any NFL team, the NFL Players Association, ESPN, Sleeper, Yahoo, or FleaFlicker. NFL team and player names are used for identification purposes only. All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

← Back to Player Explorer
Cole Payton headshot

Cole Payton

QB · #63

PHI · QB · Age 23

Dynasty value
317
◆Hold Stable
Tier
T11
Pos rank
QB63
Consensus
Contested
What’s driving the valueRange 317–365
Case for
+
Age / window
age 23 QB
Major
+
Situation
One tailwind
Minor
Case against
−
Pedigree / rank
QB63 · Tier 11
Minor
Neutral: Production trend
Analysis

The 2026 draft brought no additional same-position competition beyond his own selection, so his outlook hinges on veteran turnover ahead of him rather than fresh draft-capital threats. His day-three, FCS-level scouting profile (limited arm strength, thin high-level reps) caps his floor as a project, though his rushing production in college offers a sliver of emergency-duty equity if ever activated. Given the total lack of a near-term role, this is a hold at best for those who already have him and a speculative, very-late-round buy only for rosters with deep bench flexibility — not a priority add over the next 1-2 seasons.

Scenarios (2)
Emergency spot dutyunlikely▲ +15%
Climbs to clear backup by 2027possible▲ +10%
Intel may be outdated · updated 44 days ago
Current statusPHI
Also see:

Prospect Profile2026 Class

13.2Composite Score

Composite Breakdown

Each row compares Cole Payton to other 2026 prospects in that signal — except Class × Draft Slot, which shows the editorial multiplier applied to Cole Payton's 2026-class + draft-slot combo (baseline 1.00× = neutral).

Computed from 4 of 6 signals

  • Draft Capital25%▼~averageRound 5, Pick 166
  • Combine Athletic17%•~average
  • Rookie ADP17%
  • Expert Consensus17%▼bottom 7%
  • College Production15%
  • Class × Draft Slot9%▲+5% (1.05×)+5% (1.05×)0.60

Class rank: 11th percentile

40-Yd94%
Vertical99%
Broad100%
3-Cone53%
Shuttle46%
Speed97%
Burst99%
Agility49%
HaSS96%
SPARQ-x96%
BMI83%

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Cole Payton's Speed Score?
Cole Payton's Speed Score ranks in the 97th percentile among NFL prospects at the position.
Risk & Opportunity Analysis (2 flags)

Risk Flags

1
  • Draft Capital

    A fifth-round selection out of an FCS program, with scouting reports citing limited arm strength and thin experience against high-level competition, points to a developmental-project ceiling rather than a guaranteed backup track.

Opportunity Flags

1
  • Scheme Fit

    His college profile featured significant rushing production, which could translate into spot-duty rushing equity if he ever earns package or emergency snaps in a rush-heavy scheme.

Format Comparison

Cole Payton — Format Comparison

FormatValuevs Best
PPR SFBest317—
PPR 1QB76-241