Risk Flags
7- Age Concerns2
Hubbard turns 27 in June 2026, placing him at the typical RB value cliff. His 2025 production cratered from 1,195 yards and 10 TDs in 2024 to just 511 yards and 1 TD (3.8 YPC) in 2025, signaling potential age-related decline.
- Role Demotion Ongoing
Rico Dowdle tops the running back depth chart for the first time this season. Head coach Dave Canales hinted that Hubbard is likely to cede more carries to Rico Dowdle, noting that 'we cannot ignore the fact that Rico has been exceptional'.
- Production Decline
Hubbard's production saw a significant downturn in 2025, finishing with 511 rushing yards (3.8 yards per carry) and one touchdown while adding 30-223-3 receiving across 15 games.
- Target/Touch Competition
Jonathon Brooks is fully cleared and reportedly 'close to 100%' after a second ACL tear, and is projected as RB2 with clear breakout pedigree; AJ Dillon and Trevor Etienne further crowd the backfield, threatening Hubbard's workhorse share.
- Target Volume
Healthy Jonathon Brooks (value 2929, recovered from multiple knee injuries) is the clear succession plan; ESPN's Liz Loza projects Brooks as Carolina's RB1 with 900+ rushing yards, threatening to cap Hubbard at a timeshare ceiling in 2026.
- Offensive Context
Carolina's offense remains a developmental project with Bryce Young in Year 3 and a skill group anchored primarily by Tetairoa McMillan. Below-average passing efficiency constrains total scoring opportunity and limits the RB target volume needed to push into true RB1 territory.