Risk Flags
6- Target Volume
Tillman finished 2025 with only 21 receptions for 270 yards in 13 games, losing significant playing time to Jerry Jeudy, rookie Isaiah Bond, and rookie TE Harold Fannin Jr. The Browns are expected to keep Jeudy and Bond, and may draft a WR in the first round, further limiting Tillman's target ceiling.
- QB Competition Uncertainty
Todd Monken has left the starting QB job open between rookies Shedeur Sanders and Dillon Gabriel, creating offensive continuity concerns. Tillman had limited experience with Gabriel (per searches) and new coach has not established QB plan.
- Offensive Dysfunction
Browns finished 5-12 in 2025 with one of the league's least-potent passing attacks. New HC and defensive coordinator departures signal major coaching overhaul and continued instability.
- Contract Risk
Tillman is on the final year of his rookie deal with a ~$1.7M base salary; the Browns could clear $3.7M in cap space by releasing him. He has never surpassed 30 receptions in a season and carries an injury history, making his roster spot genuinely vulnerable heading into training camp.
- Draft Capital
Cleveland used both their R1 (KC Concepcion, #24 overall) and R2 (Denzel Boston, #39 overall) picks on WRs, effectively pushing Tillman to WR4 or worse. The Browns committed their two earliest picks to the position — a clear signal that the front office views the WR room as needing a full rebuild around Jeudy and the rookies, not Tillman.
- Contract Situation
Tillman is in the final year of his rookie deal at ~$1.7M base salary, becoming an UFA in 2027. With two higher-upside rookies now on the roster at cost-controlled deals, the Browns have every financial incentive to release or simply not activate Tillman in favor of developing Concepcion and Boston.