Risk Flags
6- Injury Concerns
Purdy's 2025 was wrecked by a turf-toe variant plus a non-throwing-shoulder issue that cost him multiple games (11 GP, QB22) and forced Mac Jones into starts; the team publicly framed the toe as something that may never fully resolve, making back-to-back injury-affected seasons a live concern.
- Chronic Shoulder Issues
Purdy battled shoulder problems that limited him to nine starts in 2025, with previous shoulder injuries in 2024 (Week 11) and stinger episodes in 2023. Pattern of recurring shoulder problems raises durability concerns despite his age.
- Turf Toe Severity
Purdy missed large portions of the year dealing with turf toe injuries, which for a QB requiring mobility and plant mechanics represents a meaningful long-term risk, especially given his smaller stature (6'1", 212 pounds) compared to typical starting QBs.
- Recurring Shoulder Injuries
Purdy has suffered multiple shoulder injuries (Week 11 2024, left shoulder in Week 1 2025, stinger in Week 18 2026) creating a pattern of recurring problems that could lead to chronic issues affecting long-term QB performance and durability.
- Offensive Weapon Loss
George Kittle tore his Achilles in the January 2026 NFC Wild Card round and will miss most or all of the 2026 season. Kittle was Purdy's most reliable red-zone and short-area target, and his absence is a meaningful hit to Purdy's TD ceiling.
- Weapons Turnover
The 49ers are expected to move on from Brandon Aiyuk, Jauan Jennings is a UFA, Ricky Pearsall has struggled with health, and George Kittle missed six games in 2025 with injuries. Offensive supporting cast faces significant turnover that could impact Purdy's efficiency.